14 Comments
User's avatar
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Aug 19
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Michael Cirigliano II's avatar

Thanks, Kate! I hadn't heard that Amy Beach work and now I'm obsessed. These are such great selections, I think I'll have to devote a future Melancholy Mixtape to just birdsong-inspired works! 💙

And The Marginalian boggles my mind. How does Maria stay so prolific year after year after year?! 🤯

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Aug 19
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Michael Cirigliano II's avatar

Such an inspiring story on every level! Popova's sentences are just so magical:

"... inside each person, even the loneliest, dwells a secret garden of delight waiting to bloom under the warm rays of tenderness ... perhaps voice only exists to give tenderness a vessel."

And I'm so glad my mixtapes bring you calm and beauty while you work! I'll have a new one out in a couple of weeks. 💙

Expand full comment
Jules's avatar

This was really enchanting, Michael. I think the Bartók was my favourite this time but all three were very enjoyable - also I love learning things like this:

"In Schoenberg's vision of atonal music, a composer isn't allowed to repeat a pitch until they've used the other 11."

Thank you!

Expand full comment
Michael Cirigliano II's avatar

Thank *you*, Jules — so glad I could send some enchantment your way today! The Bartók is such a magical experience, the first bird to enter the scene always brings a huge smile to my face. 💙

Expand full comment
Kathleen Clare Waller's avatar

These are just gorgeous, Michael. I'm listening while relaxing after a long day of unpacking in London.

Expand full comment
Michael Cirigliano II's avatar

So glad to hear you’re settling in to London, Kate! I hope these moments of birdsong proved a healing potion for you as they did for Bartók. 💙

Expand full comment
Kathleen Clare Waller's avatar

Absolutely, they do 💙

Expand full comment
Anne McMillan's avatar

Gorgeous selections, Michael. I’m a big fan of all three composers, and always love listening to Barbara Bonney. Two more bird-themed pieces come to mind: Brahms’ ‘Die Nachtigall’ and Vaughan Williams ‘The Lark Ascending.’

Thank you so much for posting such inspiring music. I enjoy reading your interesting commentary as well.

Expand full comment
Michael Cirigliano II's avatar

Thank you, Anne — I’m delighted you’re enjoying the words and music I share. (The Vaughn Williams almost made it on the list here! What a bounty of beautiful works to choose from.) 💙

What are some of your favorite Bonney recordings? I love that we can turn to her for everything from Purcell to Strauss!

Expand full comment
Chloe Hope's avatar

Michael, what a balm. Thank you. I especially appreciated hearing about the bird aiding in Bartók's healing.

Expand full comment
Michael Cirigliano II's avatar

It's such a beautiful story, isn't it? Thanks for reading, Chloe. 💙

Expand full comment
E.L. Zeitgeist's avatar

Wow 🤩 Bartók's was remarkably unique to my ears! It felt more like a play or film score, so visual! That he didn’t finish the last 17 measures of his final concerto is both haunting and oddly hopeful. Like our last breath isn’t truly the end of us.

Expand full comment
Michael Cirigliano II's avatar

I totally agree — the Bartók is so cinematic! And we can’t help but to feel drawn in by the mystery of a score left incomplete: Mozart’s Requiem, Bach’s Art of Fugue, Mahler’s Tenth Symphony (which I’ll be covering in a 2025 essay). Love your framing of the immortality of art here. 💙

Expand full comment
E.L. Zeitgeist's avatar

Ooo, Mahler! I can’t wait!

Expand full comment